Case for the only profitable route in Japan

[[[Economists May 21.. The sole reason why Shinkansen plying the Tokaido route make money is the sheer density—and affluence—of the customers they serve. Tokaido route is around 550km that connects the 35m people in greater Tokyo to the 20m residents of the Kansai cluster of cities comprising Osaka, Kobe, Kyoto and Nara. All the other Shinkansen routes in Japan lose cart-loads of cash, as high-speed trains do elsewhere in the world. Only indirect subsidies, creative accounting, political patronage and national chest-thumping keep them rolling.]]]

I cannot quote too much the article. But Economists does cast doubt if any HSR will ever be viable without huge subsidy from taxpayers. Things do not look good at all in the mainland where the formerly high-flyer head of HSR has been incarcerated.


samueln - 2011年05月22日 08:15

same to our airport express train, Shanghai's first maglift, etc.

PBrega - 2011年05月22日 15:45

The politically correct fraud is not regarded as crime. That's why every data and every statistical information are far from reality. Just like G.W.Bush era, you do not supply any true information, you can only supply the information as what the leaders want. Get it?

hepi - 2011年05月22日 21:50

Something called "national pride" is priceless to those obnoxious decision-makers. They are prepared to pay anything for it - as they have us to foot the bill!



  1. 網站編輯或網站作家開題,網友可回應。回應必須貼題,請勿重覆;勿發表誹謗,人身攻擊或不雅內容。
  2. 網站編輯有權發表或不發表網友張貼的內容。(請參閱議論守則)
  3. 開題之網友可編輯其在過去7天內發表之論題,或刪除相關回應。

查閱 FAQ

信報簡介 | 服務條款 | 私隱條款 | 免責聲明 | 廣告查詢 | 信報會議中心租賃 | 加入信報 | 聯絡信報